1991 – Kelli McCarty
1992 – Shannon Marketic
1993 – Kenya Moore
1994 – Lu Parker
1995 – Shanna Moakler
1996 – Ali Landry
1997 – Brandi Sherwood
USA 1998 – Shawnae Jebbia
1999 – Kimberly Pressler
2000 – Lynnette Cole
2001 – Kandace Krueger
2002 – Shauntay Hinton
2003 – Susie Castillo
2004 – Shandi Finnessey
2005 – Chelsea Cooley
2006 – Tara Conner
2007 – Rachel Smith
2008 — Crystle Stewart
2009 — Kristen Dalton
2010 — Rima Fakih
